Iceland Guidebook Review

The verdict from expert Dick Phillips on our Iceland guidebook.

A few words from prolific Cicerone author Paddy Dillon on meeting Iceland expert Dick Phillips, who offered tours in Iceland for over 50 years and owned the Fljótsdalur Youth Hostel, until his recent retirement. He is also possibly the toughest critic on Iceland guidebooks...

Breathtaking Views Of Iceland
Breathtaking Views Of Iceland

Paddy: "Before I went to Iceland last summer, I got in touch with him [Phillips] so that I could crouch at his feet and absorb some wisdom. He lives at Nenthead, a high-level village in Cumbria, and in fact his house is a steep bit of a climb above the village even then! Anyhow, I phoned him in January and asked if I could pop round, and he said... "Not really... the snow is 6ft deep and the road is blocked!" So, a month later I phoned again and he said... "Yes... the snow is only 2ft deep and the road has been cleared!"

When I first got in touch with him, before going to Iceland, he sent me a list of scathing reviews he'd compiled of various books about Iceland. So... I was expecting some brutal comments from him once he'd seen the book!"

It seems that Paddy needn't have worried, here's an extract from Dick Phillip's review of Walking and Trekking in Iceland:

"Some guides to Iceland are written by experts on writing guides, while others - the ones I usually prefer - are by experts on Iceland, who would not dream of writing a a guide to anywhere else. Both tend to be full of "useful" information about wonderful guest-houses, or other facilities, whose opening and shutting down does not coincide with book publication dates. Dillon's guide hardly concerns itself with such things. It is for the serious place-to-place mountain walker, not necessarily seeking out summits; unlike many guides, you know that the writer, in a prodigious programme of walking over two years, has himself trodden every step of the ways he describes, solo.

In future years, some of the waymarking signs that Dillon found will disappear, and doubtless other be added. No matter; the basic elements of the walks will still be there, and the book as useful in 50 years' time as it is today. In its field, this book is more than outstanding - it is unique."

Dick Phillips
Map of  Iceland

Paddy Dillon

Paddy Dillon is a prolific outdoor writer with over 90 guidebooks to his name, and contributions to 40 other publications. He has written for a variety of outdoor magazines, as well as many booklets and brochures for tourism organisations. Paddy lives near the Lake District and has walked in every county in England, Scotland, Ireland and Wales; writing about walks in every one of them. He enjoys simple day walks, challenging long-distance walks, and is a dedicated island-hopper. He has led guided walks and walked extensively in Europe, as well as in Nepal, Tibet, Korea, Africa and the Rocky Mountains of Canada and the United States.

View Articles and Books by Paddy Dillon

Get involved with Cicerone